Left: Bonhoeffer
As I read A Testament to Freedom, Essential Writings of Bonhoeffer, I think I’ll wrestle with what I read here. I’ve completed the introductory life, and am struck again as I was when reading Bethge’s biography of the congruence of Dietrich’s life. He seemed to see clearly and earlier than many in the run up to the Nazi era that Christ called him to die. In the warlock’s cauldron of Nazi Germany, his life was unified in the love of Christ.
What possible connection to such a life could there be with an ordinary life like mine? If he could have, Dietrich would have lived an ordinary life in the love of Christ; martyrdom was nothing he aspired to, the cult of personality he cosidered anathema.
I’ve read the selections from his dissertations. They’ll take several reads before I can grasp what he’s saying. In “The Communion of Saints” his 1930 dissertation he sees the church in Christ, not a socio-political entity, as the community of those who are in Christ, who live for Christ and for others in the world. I don’t think his views coincide with the emphasis on personal salvation that characterizes my primary faith tradition, Southern Baptists.
(I no longer consider myself Baptist or Christian—the latter indicating the traditions and attachments to faith in the past two millennia; I aspire to be a “Christ-follower” for lack of a better term. I suppose the biblical name would simply be “in Christ.”)
“Act and Being” his 1931 dissertation requires more than one read. In the intro I highlighted this:
“God’s Word becomes God’s revelation for us only in community.” (p. 65)
This is true. The word “solidarity” has become more common since the Polish labor union Solidarity successfully opposed the Communist regime. Most in the US, however, still pursue the individualistic capitalistic golden idol, and see no problem with individuals controlling vast wealth, while millions go without work, health care, food, shelter, personal safety, not to speak of the opportunity for self-realization that the middle class and well to do think of as a human right.
I also decided to jump around in the book, to avoid getting swamped in the super difficult sections like “Act and Being.” Therefore, I read
- “The Church is Dead” and
- “Learning to Die.”
But not all the dead are blessed; rather “those which die in the Lord,” those who learned how to die in time, who kept faith, who clung to Jesus up to the last hour, whether amidst the sufferings of the first martyrs, or in the martyrdom of a silent loneliness. (p. 267).
Back to the question of Dietrich’s relevance to ordinary life. I don’t think we live in ordinary times. Since Sept 11, 2001, the nation has been preoccupied with national security. Under Bush Cheney we violated some of our most cherished principles: at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, we imprison nameless people without trial indefinitely. We torture. In the emerging democracies of Eastern Europe the CIA (just like the Communists) set up a gulag where human rights were extinct.
Now with the economic downturn, millions around the world have no work. The prosperity which cushioned many from the inequities of globalization has evaporated. Huge banks which oppose welfare for individuals accept tens, hundreds of billions of dollars from a government which simply prints more when needed. Some scientists wonder if we’re headed for another mass extinction event.
We view our circumstances as normal, whereas in World War II we realized we were in crisis. The church for the most part today has gone silent on all these and many other issues, in relation to which being “in Christ” ought to bring about a beloved community where Christ is incarnate today through the metanoia and newness of life, not merely of the individual, but of the whole as one body in Christ.
Photo by Mary Fran
Some people think they are writers, but you’re a real writer. You have included many valuable, interesting views in your article. This content is a wonderful example of good writing.
I do a lot of online reading these days and have found it really hard to find good articles. I’m glad I got to read your article because it proves there is interesting online content.
I have to thank you for being so insightful and forward-thinking. Your article reflects intelligence and common sense. I thought all common sense was gone, but you proved me wrong.
Your information is very interesting. I like to see a writer write from his or her own point of view. I agree with your original content. Thank you for sharing.
I think you did an awesome job explaining it. Sure beats having to research it on my own. Thanks
You’ve made some excellent points in this article that I find very thought-provoking and stimulating. I am hoping for more from you soon. You just don’t find high quality writing like this very often online.
All writers should care about giving their readers content like this. This is intelligent, informative and original content I find accurate. I’m pretty sure there’s not another writer that can cover this topic so well.
I love it when I can tell a writer has put forth a lot of effort for their content. I’m really glad I read this.
I love reading new information on just about any topic, as long as the writing is interesting. This article is interesting. I like it. Many of the points mentioned here are valid and I concur.
I’m not one to make comments on articles very often, but this information really spoke to me. It’s interesting and invaluable content presented in a very unique way. Thank you.
You’ve gone to a lot of effort to do your research. If more writers would take the time and make the effort to state their point of view readers would learn more from their content.
I didn’t think anyone shared my views in this area. Thank you for writing this in an article. This information is written in an interesting manner with many fresh ideas.
Informative articles like this are usually dull. Instead of writing the same old same old informative content, you’ve given this kind of content an interesting boost of flavor. Thank you.
I think you did an awesome job explaining it. Sure beats having to research it on my own. Thanks
You make so many great points here that I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers.
This article is really good. I’ve enjoyed reading the original content and fresh ideas you wrote. You are good at writing on this topic and I hope I can read more of your work soon.
This content has a lot of great information that is apparently intended to make you think. There are excellent points made here and I agree on many. I like the way this content is written.
Thank you for writing this informative article. You have made sense of this topic with your original and quality content. It’s smart, engaging and interesting. Articles like this are genuinely appreciated by people like me.
Until I read your article, I thought I was well versed on this subject matter. Thank you for giving me more fresh information to add to my knowledge to make me an even better teacher.
I find this article very interesting and well-written. I like the writer’s point of view in much of this content. This content is just right.
I’m amazed at how interesting this article is, especially on this subject. You have hit the ball out of the ballpark with this. Thank you for making this content so easy to read and understand.
The points you have mentioned in this content are unique and intelligent. This is a very good article that I will read again very soon.
There’s more to this content than just good writing style. I think you have expressed your points in an articulate and interesting manner. Thank you.
I would be interested to know how long it took you to pump out this information. I think it’s great. I completely agree and you are very insightful. Thank you.
Excellent article! You’ve used relevant material and valid points in this content. I agree with a lot your views. This is engaging and well worded.
I admire you for writing this excellent article. This information is well-researched and interesting. I became so involved in this content that I couldn’t make myself quit reading. Thank you for producing great quality work.
Interesting… I’m going to blog about that too…
In my opinion, you’ve presented the topic in a quite thorough yet concise manner, that is genuinely useful when someone wants to get the facts without spending too a lot time searching the Internet and sifting out the noise to discover the answers to their questions.
I stayed away from these kinds of articles for quite a while, but you have taken me to whole new level of reading enjoyment. I really appreciate your hard work.
Wonderful article! I appreciate good writing and this is just that; really good writing. You kept me interested from the first sentence to the last and I agree completely on each point you’ve made here.
I must say you are very skilled at persuasive writing if you can convince me to share your views. I am very impressed by your excellent writing abilities. Please keep up the good informational writing.
You are utterly correct on that!
Very interesting subject, regards for posting.
Good informative content is written to target the thinking person. This content is brain-challenging yet straightforward. The viewpoints are written with a lot of thought and prep work behind them.
I chose to bookmark this site so I can come back and read it again. It’s extremely well-written and it draws you into the information provided. This is excellent writing.
Informative articles like this impress me. I think these points made are fresh and original and I agree with a lot of this content. Thank you for your great writing.
I feel the need to thank you for your great writing ability and unique content. Your article reflects many of my same views. You have written some very interesting content.
I am interested in several points in this article. I have had to put on my thinking cap to take in and consider some of this original thinking. Thank you for sharing this useful information.
Good writing skills take more than just education. It’s passion that sets the good and great writers apart. I see you have passion and skills.
I can’t top other comments made here, but I do think you are a great writer with a lot of talent. You’re points match my opinion almost to a tee.
I appreciate your take on this informative content. It’s immersing, specific, straightforward and very unique. I agree with a lot of your ideas and thoughts. You are a brilliant writer with a lot of intelligence.
Thank you for your devotion to excellence in writing. While reading your article I related to the points made in this content. This is good.
Wonderful presentation! You’ve represented your points quite well in this article. Not many people are focused enough to write this well. Thank you so much.
I am glad I found your article. Your content is like a breath of fresh air in an otherwise polluted sea of confusing content. Your article is interesting and original.
This is a terrific article. You make sense with your views and I agree with you on many. Some information got me thinking. That’s a sign of a great article.
I know when I’m reading quality content when I can’t stop. I got involved in this article and missed my lunch. It was worth it.
I am grateful for this valid information. You have represented your points in an insightful and interesting way. I’ve read other writings on similar topics that were boring and ineffectual. Yours is easier to digest.
I have honestly enjoyed reading the information you have shared through this article. I agree on most all points of interest, but I need to consider some with much thought.
Your original take on this topic has me thinking about many of the points you shared in this article. This is great content with substance.
I’m trying to imagine how much planning and research it took for you to write this unique article. I’m sure you had to really dig deep and buckle down to write such interesting original content.